Where to Eat at Disney’s Old Key West Resort
Old Key West has a table service restaurant, two quick service locations, and a bar. If you have an upcoming stay at Old Key West, where should you eat?
Table Service
Olivia’s Cafe
If you’re looking for a taste of the Florida Keys, head to Olivia’s Cafe in the Hospitality House. The restaurant feels like the neighborhood gem of the fictional Conch Flats community where Old Key West Resort is located. As the story goes, Olivia Farnsworth, a longtime resident of Conch Flats, used to invite passersby to her cottage on Turtle Krawl to enjoy her home cooking before she eventually opened the cafe.
Currently, Olivia’s serves brunch from 7:30am to 2pm and then dinner from 5pm to 9pm. Starting on October 6, Olivia’s will instead serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Some of the must-try dishes include the crab cake eggs Benedict, banana bread French toast, conch fritters, southernmost buttermilk chicken, and shrimp and grits. Don’t forget to leave room for Olivia’s bananas foster or the Key lime pie!
If you don’t feel like dining at the restaurant and prefer to enjoy your spacious Old Key West villa, you always place an order to go through the My Disney Experience app.
Quick Service
Good’s Food to Go
Also at the Hospitality House is Good’s Food to Go, the quick service kiosk at Old Key West. This spot is open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. While it doesn’t have any indoor seating, you can find a picnic table by the feature pool. For breakfast, you’ll find a breakfast wrap, Mickey waffle, and a basic breakfast platter with eggs, Mickey waffles, bacon, sausage, and potatoes. For lunch and dinner, the menus are the same: cheese dogs, hot dogs, cheeseburgers, chicken strips, sandwiches, salads, and a soup of the day.
If you enjoy having a resort refillable mug, you can purchase and refill yours at Good’s Food to Go.
Turtle Shack Poolside Snacks
Right by the Turtle Pond Pool near Buildings 41 and 42 is Turtle Shack Poolside Snacks. This quick service/pool bar location offers quick bites like a charcuterie plate, pizza, hot dogs, sandwiches, and salads as well as snacks like cookies, Mickey bars, Mickey ice cream sandwiches, and fruit cups. You can also get slushies, beer, cocktails, and refills for your resort refillable mug.
Bar
Gurgling Suitcase
This small bar in the Hospitality House offers a variety of beer, wine, and cocktails. It also a small menu of bites, including a bacon jam cheeseburger and several appetizers, such as a spinach and artichoke dip, soup of the day, hushpuppies, pickle chips, chips and guacamole, and pulled pork nachos.
Nearby Dining Options
The options are somewhat limited while staying at Old Key West, but you are also a walk or boat ride away from Disney Springs. From quick service dining like Polite Pig, D-Luxe Burger, and Earl of Sandwich to table service dining like Chef Art Smith’s Homecomin’, The Boathouse, and Summer House on the Lake, you have plenty of options for dining.
Start planning your next Disney vacation! Browse the confirmed reservations, or request a free quote to rent DVC points and save up to 65% compared to booking directly through Disney.
